Germany’s taxpayer-funded public broadcaster ZDF has provoked a backlash after its flagship news program Heute Journal was caught airing an AI-generated video depicting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents arresting a woman and children during an enforcement operation.
ZDF used the fake video during an anti-Trump report on U.S. immigration enforcement.
The February 15 segment triggered immediate backlash on social media after viewers spotted an OpenAI “Sora” watermark embedded in the footage.
The logo, which is only visible at the end of the clip, makes it unmistakably clear that the scenes were synthetic.
The broadcast showed a crying woman and two children being led away by ICE agents, who were referred to during the segment as “troops.”
Critics quickly pointed out that while AI-generated visuals are becoming increasingly realistic, the visible watermark left little doubt that the images were not authentic.
WATCH:
“Editorial Oversight” Claim
Following the uproar, ZDF acknowledged the error and expressed regret.
When pressed about the incident, the broadcaster stated that the AI-generated images should have been clearly labeled.
According to ZDF:
“This marking was not transferred when the article was transferred for technical reasons.”
ZDF has since removed the synthetic sequences and replaced them with what it described as authentic video and still images.
The updated version now carries a disclaimer reading:
“Video subsequently changed for editorial reasons.”
However, the network declined to clarify whether the footage was created internally or whether the editorial staff was aware at the time of the original broadcast that the material was AI-generated.
That unanswered question has intensified scrutiny.
Transparency Questions
ZDF responded to the controversy by reiterating its internal standards, stating:
“ZDF’s AI principles stipulate that AI-generated images are always transparently labeled.”
The problem in this case is that the labeling failed during broadcast, meaning viewers were shown fabricated arrest footage presented within a news report about U.S. immigration enforcement.
The situation escalated further when the original version of the segment was temporarily removed from YouTube and ZDF’s media library.
Some outlets reported that the broadcaster had “deleted its fake video.”
ZDF pushed back on that characterization, explaining that the removal was only temporary while the segment was edited.
Still, the episode has raised broader concerns about how frequently AI-generated visuals may have appeared in news reporting without proper disclosure.
Billions in Public Funding
ZDF is not a private media outlet operating on ad revenue.
It is funded through mandatory household payments.
German households are required to pay nearly €20 per month to finance public broadcasters such as ZDF and ARD, a system that generates billions annually.
The controversy is likely to fuel criticism from conservatives who have long accused Germany’s public broadcasters of ideological bias, particularly in their coverage of immigration and in reporting involving the Alternative for Germany (AfD).
Critics have also pointed to what they describe as disproportionately low representation of AfD figures on public broadcasting programs.
Now, with AI-generated footage of ICE arrests aired without proper labeling, questions are mounting about editorial standards, political framing, and the role of synthetic media in taxpayer-funded journalism.
The incident underscores a growing challenge for media organizations worldwide: as artificial intelligence becomes more powerful, transparency is no longer optional, especially when public trust and public funding are on the line.
Our comment section is restricted to members of the Slay News community only.
To join, create a free account HERE.
If you are already a member, log in HERE.